Jakarta, 31 August 2026 — AFS Chambers has once again secured a victory for its client, PT Triniti Menara Serpong, successfully defending the company as the defendant in two simple civil claims brought by consumers. The cases were heard before the Tangerang District Court under Case No. 119/Pdt.G.S/2026/PN Tng and Case No. 120/Pdt.G.S/2026/PN Tng.
In their claims, the plaintiffs alleged that the cancellation of the conditional sale and purchase agreements, the buyback, and the eviction of the apartment units constituted a breach of contract by the defendant. In its defense, AFS Chambers argued that it was, in fact, the plaintiffs who had committed a breach of contract, as they had failed to fulfill their payment obligations under the credit facilities provided by the bank. Accordingly, AFS Chambers argued that the relevant bank should also have been joined as a party to the proceedings. Furthermore, AFS Chambers maintained that the cancellation of the agreements, the buyback, and the eviction had been carried out under the contract provision and constituted the legal consequences of the plaintiffs’ breach of contract.
The Panel of Judges ultimately accepted AFS Chambers’ arguments and declared the plaintiffs’ claims inadmissible. In its consideration, the Panel of Judges found that the bank should have been included as a party to the proceedings. Consequently, the dispute could not be classified as a simple claim.
This achievement further demonstrates AFS Chambers’ commitment to protecting its clients’ legal rights while upholding procedural integrity and legal certainty. Adrian Fernando, Managing Partner of AFS Chambers, stated: “At AFS Chambers, we are always guided by legal certainty in our pursuit of justice, in formulating our legal arguments, and in defending our clients’ rights. We will always strive to deliver measured victories for each and every one of our clients.”


