Jakarta, 30 July 2026 – Since the enactment of Law No. 20 of 2025 on the Criminal Procedure Code (Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Pidana “KUHAP”), which entry into force on 2 January 2026, Indonesia’s criminal justice system has recognized a new type of judicial decision known as the judicial pardon (rechterlijk pardon).
Article 1 point 19 of KUHAP defines a “Judicial Pardon” as a judgment declaring the defendant guilty, but, in light of the minor nature of the offence, the offender’s personal circumstances, the circumstances under which the offence was committed, and the circumstances arising after the offence, judges refrain from imposing either a criminal punishment or a corrective measure, while giving due consideration to the principles of justice and humanity. This provision is further reaffirmed in Article 246 (1) of KUHAP.
This concept differs fundamentally from an acquittal. In an acquittal, the defendant is found not guilty since the criminal offence has not been proven. Otherwise, in a judicial pardon, every element of the criminal offence has been proven, and the defendant is therefore still found guilty. The only distinction lies in the operative part of the judgment, judges determine not to impose a criminal sentence, having concluded that punishment is no longer the most just means of achieving the objectives of the law. The concept of a Judicial Pardon is in line with Article 54 (1) of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code, which requires judges to consider various circumstances before imposing a sentence, including the nature of the offence, the offender’s personal circumstances, the impact of the criminal offence, and, where relevant, forgiveness extended by the victim or the victim’s family.
The application of this concept is no longer merely theoretical. In one of the notable decision on judicial pardon, namely the District Court of Balige Decision No. 171/Pid/B/2025/PN Blg dated 24 February 2026, the Panel of Judges relied on the following considerations in granting a judicial pardon:
- The minor nature of the offence, namely the assault committed by the defendant resulted only in minor injuries;
- The defendant’s personal circumstances, namely that the defendant had admitted the offence, undertaken not to repeat the conduct, had no prior criminal record, and was the mother of young children as well as female breadwinner; and
- The circumstances at the time of and following the commission of the offence, namely that the assault arose out of an argument between the victim and the defendant, and that the defendant had already suffered social stigma and condemnation as a consequence of the offence.
In addition to the above decision, there are at least 6 (six) other judicial pardon decisions demonstrating that this mechanism has begun to be applied in cases involving assault, criminal threats, and petty theft, including:
- District Court of Pacitan Decision No. 1/Pid.C/2026/PN Pct dated 20 January 2026;
- District Court of Gedong Tataan Decision No. 1/Pid.C/2026/PN Gdt dated 22 January 2026;
- District Court of Garut Decision No. 412/Pid.B/2025/PN Grt dated 26 January 2026;
- District Court of Sangatta Decision No. 512/Pid.B/2025/PN Sgt dated 11 February 2026;
- District Court of Kotabaru Decision No. 1/Pid.C/2026/PN Kbr dated 20 April 2026; and
- District Court of Kotabaru Decision No. 2/Pid.C/2026/PN Kbr dated 20 April 2026.
Therefore, a judicial pardon does not constitute an exemption from criminal liability. Rather, it serves as a legal mechanism that empowers judges to uphold substantive justice in circumstances where the imposition of a criminal sentence is no longer the most proportionate means of achieving justice, notwithstanding that the defendant’s guilt has been established lawfully and beyond reasonable doubt.


